« Punked | Main | The Perils of Political Maternalism »

Moonshine Patriots: A Note on E.L. Doctorow

By Charles O'Brien

Thomas Mann left Germany when Hitler came to power. He spent the Reich’s twelve years in exile, stripped of his citizenship, a proud enemy of the German state. Here’s a question: which was the greater patriot, Mann or Hitler? Hitler, after all, undid Versailles, created a Grossdeutschland, and reduced the heart of Europe to a slave market (and worse). Mann spent the war years under the palm trees of Southern California, while those back home spent those years under incessant Allied bombing.

And here’s the answer: which was right?

When Michael Moore tells audiences in Europe that Americans are stupid, is he unpatriotic? Don’t jump to anything. If Michael Moore, in his wisdom, has determined that Americans are not rocket scientists and brain surgeons, he should say so. Better that we were steered away from such endeavors as rocket science and brain surgery. But he said it in Europe. Yes, and now Europeans, knowing our incapacity, will know to make allowances. And besides, if he had said it here, he’d have to explain it 278,000,000 times. Is he unpatriotic?

Here’s the answer: It’s Michael Moore, and you’d be a fool to believe him.

In the weeks after 9/11, American flags were all over the place. Yet military enlistments did not go much beyond an uptick; certainly, military-age men out of uniform were nowhere handed the white feather. How much real patriotism there was is an open question; and how much there ought to have been is, some would add, subject to debate. And yet – patriotism, the word, if not the thing – has become quite a sore point in today’s politics. Whatever 9/11’s final legacy, it has given us two surprisingly durable catchphrases: “Don’t question my patriotism” (with variants, How dare you, etc.) and “Dissent Is Patriotic.”

There was a need. What might the word “patriotism” suggest? You come from somewhere. You haven’t moved away. Who, in some sense, isn’t a patriot? Who needs to insist on it? A flaunted patriotism is hard to distinguish from undesirable neighbors like chauvinism, jingoism, xenophobia. A too simple patriotism bespeaks some lack of a critical faculty. Better to be wised up.

But if patriotism may not be an unmixed good, to be perceived as lacking patriotism is clearly a thing to be avoided. The associations of the word “unpatriotic” are all bad: untrustworthy, ingrate, whoring after strange gods, pretentious, superior – and worse. “Don’t question my patriotism” doesn’t fully say, “I am a patriot.” Rather, it quietly acknowledges that my claims on patriotism probably don’t look all that solid, and it demands that I be spared all the negative associations of the word “unpatriotic” (associations which, to be fair, are not yet proved). The trouble, though, is that it is very rare that any political actor’s “patriotism” actually is “questioned”. Often some of the negatives associated with the lack of patriotism cling to a political actor. The demand, “Don’t question my patriotism” is a demand, in advance, for a clean bill of political health; and that demand can’t reasonably be made.

“Dissent Is Patriotic” is a larger muddle. Is dissent patriotic? Wouldn’t that depend on the particulars of the dissent? A difference of opinion does not constitute treason and so invite capital punishment; and nobody says it does. “Dissent” may take many forms, from wearing a “Dissent Is Patriotic” button to taking up arms for the Taliban. The button wearer may be crazy in love with America, or detest her heartily. Looking at a button, who can know? Even a Taliban foot soldier may profess his love for the U.S.: John Lindh said that he was fine with America, it was the Northern Alliance he couldn’t abide.

What is dissent in the first place? Russ Feingold, voting against the Iraq war is a dissenter. Barry Goldwater voting against the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and Jesse Helms voting against the King Holiday are – what exactly? “Dissent” is the minority viewpoint you approve of. Can it be justified? Justified! It’s dissent and must be embraced. Dissent is what heroes do and is above criticism. “Dissent Is Patriotic”, rightly understood, means, “My wholly admirable opinions are wholly admirable”. The logic is flawless, once the premise is granted – which the delusional are happy to do.

The great invokers of patriotism today will be found among the anti-war movement, and not among the Brent Scowcrofts or the Pat Buchanans. Today’s patriots are the progressives. And those patriots have raised the matter of American military casualties as a major – probably the major – argument against the Iraq war. Only look at Cindy Sheehan’s ongoing celebrity.

That American military casualties are a bad thing most people will agree, domestically. Those casualties, though, say very little about the merits of the war. If you think that the Allied bombing of German and Japanese cities during World War II was a great crime, it will not be because quite a few Allied planes were shot down: the deaths in the air were a tiny fraction of the deaths on the ground. But if you think the bombing was an essential part of the war effort, the dead aviators will be seen as the inevitable cost of victory. If you think that Sherman’s March was a great crime, Union casualties shouldn’t matter that much. If you believe that Sherman’s March was the thing that effectively ended chattel slavery in North America, you will look at the Union casualties and think that the Battle Hymn of the Republic was there made real.

There is a button that says, “Iraq is Arabic for Vietnam”, and it would make a nice three-hour final exam somewhere to list some of the many ways the statement is false. Truer is that Iraq protest is the degenerate offspring of Vietnam protest. Iraq must be Vietnam, even without similarities, because the response is identical. Iraq protest has looked back at Vietnam protest and learned (just the wrong things). Vietnam protest, against expectation, convinced only the convinced. As protests grew, support for the war grew. What finally turned the public against the war was an appreciation of the war's costs – American military deaths, specifically – with no perceptible end in sight. Iraq protest (apart from its fringes) knew from day one to emphasize, before the fact, quagmire, and as the numbers started to come in, military casualties. There’s been no shortage of contrived atrocity stories, of course, but these are kept strictly apart from the telling of the deaths (falsely: the death toll – includes accidents, which are common in the military even in peacetime). Is Iraq worth it? Don’t ask. Just look at those numbers, approaching the highly significant 3,000, then passing it, and even worse – not going down.

How should deaths in war be seen, or to ask it another way, how much is too much? 3,000 is a key number. Opponents of the Afghan war were eager to inflate civilian casualties there – if you could get them to over 3,000, we were quits for 9/11. People talking up the complaints of the Arabs in Palestine often referred to the Sabra and Shatilla massacres, where somewhere between 400 and 800 were killed. The Arab side usually blew this up to 1,000–1,500. After 9/11, though, in one writer’s version this became 1,500 – 3,000. One incautious Bush critic expressed the hope that Katrina’s dead would hit the magic 3,000. Try another number. Before the first Gulf War, Saddam said that he wasn’t worried about the Americans – they weren’t tough enough to absorb 10,000 killed in a single battle. If he’s right, we’re in trouble. If he’s even perceived to be right – witness his failure to capitulate – twice! – or Usaama bin Laadin’s harping on the 18 dead at Mogadishu – we’re in trouble. Try another number. The number of those killed in Sudan alone at the hands of jihad/genocidal Arab racism is already well over 2,000,000, and given the Arab League, China, the E.U., the U.N., and the constraints on the current administration, it is likely to hit 3,000,000 before very long. How high will the numbers in the ongoing world war go? Even if the U.S. and Israel withdrew from the war (as if they could), it would go in Africa, in Russia, in the Indian subcontinent, in Western Europe, in Thailand, in the Philippines, hardly anywhere untouched. The dead now are at seven figures. While the dead are almost certain to go to eight figures, it is not unreasonable to hope that the final count will stop short of 100,000,000. Who knows? Even domestically, right after 9/11 most people felt sure that worse was on the way, cities very possibly disappearing, and millions of lives with them.

What if we tally only military deaths? When career soldiers look back at a military cemetery, they see not failure but glory. When they see columns of names on a war memorial, they don’t wonder how this could have happened. When military commanders sum up in their campaign memoirs, this sentence does not appear: “Thankfully, no-one was hurt.” Military personnel face death with eyes open. Firefighters are a useful comparison. Most of the anti-war claims about military deaths could be made with as much justice about firefighters killed on the job. Who wants to be the last man into a collapsing building? Why doesn’t the mayor send his children into the Fire Department? (So far, though, flames haven’t been called the Resistance.) Remember that the 343 firefighters killed at the Twin Towers outnumbered the fewer than 200 Americans killed in the whole run from Dohai to Saddam’s statue in Firdos Square in Baghdad, and remember too that those numbers don’t really say anything. And when the 3,000th American “combat” death is reported and the opinion pieces pour forth, brim full of mourning and indignation, remember that most of these pieces, awaiting only a date and a detail or two, are sitting on hard drives today.

For a preview of those pieces, you can look – actually we can look a lot of places, but we will be looking at E. L. Doctorow’s "An Essay on our President" (available at www.ocmus.net/artman/publish/printer_23788.shtml). American boys are dying, says Doctorow.

But this President doesn’t know what death is.

It seems unlikely. This denial of expertise, this business of “You don’t know what x is" is a commonplace. You may know what a whiffleball looks like, but unless you devote all your free time to the game, you don’t know whiffleball. Maybe not. But no-one is expert in death. The four-year-old who understands that the pet parakeet will chirp no more and the mortician know pretty equally how the thing works. What supports Doctorow’s implicit claim to know better than Bush what death is? Ed Doctorow is very much a New Yorker. George Bush, as Hans Koning has reminded us, is headed back to his farm in Texas when he leaves office. It is rare for a New Yorker to see anything bigger and deader in its natural state than a pigeon. Life on a farm is exposure to life cycles, very much including large, unmediated animal corpses. In New York, el dia de los muertos is the decor at a happy hour; in Texas it is living, public tradition. And where Texas’s foundational legend is a massacre, New York’s is a real estate transaction. Put another way, how would Doctorow know?

Well, he says. He offers three proofs.

First, there’s this:

On the eve of D-Day in 1944 General Eisenhower prayed to God for the lives of the young soldiers he knew were going to die. He knew what death was. Even in a justifiable war, a war not of choice but of necessity, a war of survival; the cost was almost more than Eisenhower could bear.

The first sentence is unexceptionable. The second is nonsense. The third sentence needs looking at. A “justifiable war” = “a war of not of choice but of necessity” = “a war of survival”, all the very opposites of the Iraq war. But our current war is a justifiable war, is a war not of choice but of necessity, is a war of survival. Could the U.S. have stayed out of World War II? An alternative-historian might say, Of course. We may say that we can’t know, because Roosevelt’s administration was not willing to stay out. For the U.S., World War II was a war of choice before it was a war of necessity. It was both, and the opposition is a false one; and the same is true for our war today. Doctorow’s equation, World War II/Iraq war is faulty, too. The Iraq war is a front in the unfortunately named Global War on Terror. Iraq was never to be the end of it. The proper comparison is WWII/GWOT - and the particular fronts should be compared: in the earlier war, Sicily, Crete, North Africa, the Philippines, Normandy, and today – so far – Afghanistan and Iraq. Landing an army on Omaha Beach is every bit as much a matter of “choice not necessity” as landing one at Um al-Qasr.

Eisenhower was pained, and Eisenhower prayed, says Doctorow, and he adds,

the cost was almost more than Eisenhower could bear.

Well, no. Eisenhower was quite aware of his responsibilities, but we may be sure that a couple of minutes after midnight on June 5, 1944, Eisenhower was never going to pick up the phone and say, “I’ve been thinking. Let’s just cancel.” Here’s what makes Doctorow’s invocation a cheap shot. Eisenshower felt it, and his posthumous papers prove it. George Bush’s posthumous papers say nothing, and therefore, we may confidently say that his pained thoughts, his prayers, are non-existent.

Second, Doctorow has caught George Bush smiling.

You see him joking with the press, peering under the table for the WMDs he can’t seem to find.

He made a joke! Yet people have been known to mount the scaffold and make a joke just before they got it in the neck, knowing full well that they would not be there all week. Doctorow goes on:

He does not mourn... How can he mourn... So he can never mourn... And so he never drops to his knees, he is not contrite, he does not sit in the church with the grieving parents and wives and children…

Article II of the United State Constitution says nothing about tears. If Doctorow had his way, foreign dignitaries would show up at a dimly lit White House only to be told, “Now is not a good time. Anyway, he’s not here.” It’s not Bush’s job to be Weeper-in-Chief. He may “joke with the press” – it almost is his job. If Mother Sheehan, like Niobe all tears, absolute moral authority, is accused of having the time of her life, Doctorow – and his audience – would consider the charge grossly unfair, a virtual blasphemy. Bush, who never claimed to be the emblem of Grief, becomess, for “joking,” for “strutting”, for “smiling”,

the [!] President who does not feel.

Third, Doctorow writes,

But, you study him; you look into his eyes and know he dissembles an emotion, which he does not feel in the depths of his being because he has not capacity for it.

A few years ago, Bush said that he looked into Vladimir Putin’s soul. That didn’t work out too well, and the statement was obviously ill-considered even as it was being made. E.L. Doctorow has not looked into George W. Bush’s soul. But he has seen him on tv.

To recap: Doctorow hasn’t read Bush’s archives; he’s aware that Bush smiles; he’s seen him on tv. What there is to know about George Bush’s interior life, E.L. Doctorow knows.

Doctorow’s little “Essay” fits in a surprising amount of empty talk and repetition. Its only interest is as specimen, not argument. Let’s do a little tour.

How then can he mourn? To mourn is to express regret and he regrets nothing.

It is impossible to gauge the ratio of dimness to slickness in such claims. One can mourn quietly, expressing nothing. One can express “regret", or anything else ,without meaning a word of it. “Express” and “mourn” have no particular business being in the same sentence. And what does “regret” mean here? You regret the days of your youth, which can’t be called back – either because they were your best time, or because you did terrible things then. But the word regret is being used in two different senses. In Doctorow’s sentence, if mourning is regretting, it is not regretting as wishing undone; yet his sentence ends that way. Doctorow waves at actual people's emotions and actions from a safe distance, and he ends with a demand for a confession.

The press is not permitted to photograph the arrival of coffins from Iraq.

Another rehashed complaint. The military is not hiding its casualties. Military funerals are very public, very formal occasions, and military cemeteries are scrupulously maintained places open to the public. Caskets in transit, no more than autopsy photos, are not there for public display. A feeling for ceremony distinguishes the military from a Wes Craven movie. Besides, why should the military help with the production of propaganda whose only aim is the defeat of the military’s mission?

He does not regret that his reason for going to war was, as he knows, unsubstantiated by the facts.

It is a little challenging to write about the war because so many falsehoods can be trotted out so casually and piled up, as Doctorow does here. By “reason”, Doctorow means WMD. But there were always multiple reasons, and the unmourning, unfeeling, unmindful President and his administration always said so. By “unsubstantiated”, Doctorow presumably means that there were no WMDs. In fact, there were WMDs: chemical and biological, and a nuclear program. The previously existing WMDs are not now non-existent but unaccounted for. A quicker war on Saddam, bypassing the U.N. altogether, would have been far better. By “as he knew”, Doctorow means, of course that Bush lied! But if Bush knew, (Bush, who "hasn’t the mind for it"), he knew better than anyone else in the world, better than Saddam’s own generals.

He does not regret that his bungled plan for the war’s aftermath has made of his mission-accomplished a disaster.

What bungled plan? There was a tentative plan, that has adjusted to changing facts. George W. Bush, able dialectician that he is, has remained calm throughout. Doctorow complains of the “war’s aftermath”. In fact, the war is ongoing, like it or not, and even the Iraq stage of the war is not completed. Bush in his U.S.S. Lincoln speech announced – accurately – the end of major combat operations in Iraq. And Doctorow is happy to talk of the war’s aftermath to avoid talking about the brilliance of the military campaign from March 19 to April 9, 2003. The “his” in “his mission-accomplished” is also misleading. The banner was not put up by the White House. It was the troops reporting to their Commander-in-Chief. And let’s be clear on what “mission accomplished” means. Go back to Eisenhower and D-Day. On June 6, 1944, the Allied armies might have been repulsed, with mass casualties, the survivors barely making it back to England. Instead, when night fell, they held the beaches and had broken the German front line. They were nowhere near Paris, let alone the German border, and the war had almost a year to run. Still, their mission had been accomplished. Bush’s troops had every right to say the same thing. As for disaster, on May 21, 2006, Iraq, after three successful elections, formed a new government.

The president knew it would be difficult for Americans not to cheer the overthrow of a foreign dictator. He knew that much.

He knew that much. And Doctorow knows better. It would be difficult for Americans not to cheer. It’s apparently something they have no control over. And the difficulty is something Doctorow himself does not share.

The president and his supporters would seem to have a mind for only one thing – to take power, to remain in power, and to use that power for the sake of themselves and their friends.

Surely, Doctorow’s “only one thing” is three things. Bush “took power” with the 2000 election. It was not a clean win, and he took office under a cloud. But so would Gore have, and the term “President-select” would have been thrown at him too. Bush “remains in power” because he won re-election. How that power is used is a big subject, but let’s zero in on the phrase “their friends”. Just who are these “friends”? This is how politics gets explained to a toddler. The President’s friends have a club called the Cabinet, and they all meet in the big white house. Who are Bush’s friends? If Tony Blair is one, Bush may well cost him his job. If Dick Cheney is one, Bush forced him to take a massive salary cut. Cheney also had to divest himself of Halliburton stock – and we all know that Iraq was invaded in order to enrich Halliburton. (Michael Moore, who has held on to his Halliburton stock, must therefore be Bush’s friend.) Who are Bush’s friends, if we exclude his political associates, who are not exactly friends? I can name one: Michael W. Smith, the CCM singer, whom his friends call W, and who, intriguingly, has dinner with the other W every week. So, the Bush administration is explained: six years and counting of favors for Michael W. Smith.

Bush “does not feel”, and Doctorow invokes not just those killed in Iraq, but the poor, the uninsured, the miners, bien d’autres. There’s something charming in the way Doctorow smuggles in domestic issues, piggybacked on the war dead. Especially nice is E.L. Doctorow writing these words – “the thirty five million of us who live in poverty.” E.L. Doctorow, in a government yard in-a Trenchtown.

But if these domestic issues are to be taken seriously – and the author of “An Essay on our President” expects to be taken seriously – shouldn’t they be, uh, argued? And it is not much of an argument to call the other side unfeeling.

But he will dissemble feeling. He will say in all sincerity he relieving the wealthiest one percent of the population of their tax burden for the sake of the rest of us, and that he is polluting the air we breathe fro the sake of our economy, and that he is decreasing the safety regulations for coal mines to save the coal miners’ jobs, and that he is depriving workers of their time-and-a half benefits for overtime because this is actually a way to honor them by raising them into the professional class. And this litany of lies he will versify with reverences for God and the flag and democracy.

He will “dissemble feeling”, says Doctorow, dissembling English. And “he will say…that he is polluting the air we breathe”. He will say no such thing, and if he did, it wouldn’t be true: he can’t pollute the air. He “will say” all these things “in all sincerity”, even as he “dissembles” and “versifies” a “litany of lies”. Doctorow’s Bush is an utter simpleton and the most cunning of liars. No wonder Doctorow’s despondent.

But there is one more terribly sad thing about all of this. I remember the millions of people who marched against the war. It was extraordinary, that spontaneously aroused oversoul of alarm and protest that transcended national borders. Why did it happen? After all, this was not the only war anyone had ever seen coming. There are little wars all over the world most of the time. But the cry of protest was the appalled understanding of millions of people that America was ceding its role as the last best hope of mankind. It was their perception that the classic archetype democracy was morphing into a rogue nation.

And at last, the big lie. It is canny of Doctorow to concede that "this war was not the only war". He, of course, will not go on to admit that “The world says no to war” was a simple untruth. The world has never said no to war. At times, though, the very worst political instincts have held extraordinary sway over extraordinary numbers of people. The anti-war/pro-Saddam protests – February 15, 2003 was the big one (what the columnist David Warren called “Biblical depravity") – are on record. Newspapers covered them, C-SPAN broadcast them, and at least one book on February 15 has been published. Will anybody be fooled by the claim that they represented a hurt love for America? Demonstrations in London were very much in the spirit of Harold Pinter, Robert Fisk, and the LRB editorial board. Those in Germany were in the spirit of the ‘80s peace movement, 1945’s losers feeling their oats. Those in Spain were in the spirit of the locals in Whit Stillman’s Barcelona. Those in France were in the spirit of the 60’s graffiti US = SS. Those in Arab capitals were the same old genocidal Arab racism. And here, there were lots of American flags, because, as we know Dissent Is Patriotic – and lots of those flags were altered in unflattering ways; but there were also lots of Iraqi and “Palestinian” flags too. There were lots of swastikas and stars of David and lots of caricatures of Ariel Sharon. At one demonstration (although not Feb. 15), a portrait of A.Q. Khan was prominently displayed on the podium. And while there were a few first-timers, the core demographic had been here before. The constant references to Vietnam were proof enough, along with the profusion of tangential foreign policy issues (Philippines, the Koreas), and the “Free, free Palestine” chanting. Doctorow calls it spontaneous. International ANSWER has organized the major demonstrations. Precisely because ANSWER’s auspices were so questionable, people who opposed the war and wanted Saddam to remain in power formed United for Peace and Justice, and later, Win Without War. Give these groups credit: ANSWER for having skills as organizers and UPJ and Win Without War for recognizing a problem and trying to work around it. Give Doctorow credit for – well no, he made it up

The greatest democratic republic in history was turning its back on the future, using its extraordinary power and standing not to advance the ideal of a concordance of civilizations but to endorse the kind of tribal combat that originated with the Neanderthals, a people, not extinct, who could imagine ensuring their survival by no other means than pre-emptive war.

Doctorow goes out on a cartoonish note. He talks casually about the “future”. We are living in times that are, among other things, exhilarating. Old suppositions have blown away. Not many people today will imagine the future as a simple extension of the present. Doctorow’s future is easy – the way it used to be and then some. Doctorow refers to “the ideal of a concordance of civilizations.” Let’s look at a little recent history. A few years back, NASA launched the Columbia space shuttle . The vehicle exploded, and the crew, which included an Indian and an Israeli - concordance enough? -was killed. In Dar al-Islam, the explosion was cheered. Christians, Jews and Hindus had all been killed. After the Tsumani, the most effective bringer of relief was the US military, George Bush’s military. After Hurricane Katrina killed hundreds of Americans, black and white alike, it was celebrated in Dar al-Islam as a soldier of al-Lah. Bush visited India recently and agreed to provide nuclear material to that great nation. George Bush did not massacre civilians in Madrid, London, Bali, Beslan. A harmony among disparate “civilizations” is certainly conceivable. Just, the discordant voice is not George Bush’s. And savor the words: “he endorses the kind of tribal combat.” Bush has, in fact, devoted his presidency in large part to fostering national governments in Afghanistan and Iraq. And then we meet:

the Neanderthals, a people, now extinct, who could imagine ensuring their survival by no other means than pre-emptive war.

“No other means”? They never tried procreation? As far as extinction goes, Bush supporters have a clear demographic edge on Nation readers. And did Neanderthals really conceptualize pre-emptive war? Did they become extinct only after they abjured the Treaty of Westphalia? Doctorow should be more circumspect about the Neanderthals. What happened to the Geico pitchman could happen to him.

Opposition to the war is, in all but a few instances, a conviction of its immorality. The enemy is not an enemy, and all the wrong people are being killed. Most of America believes none of this. The palatable substitute for such deeply unpopular views is the fake pro-military stance. Mother Sheehan becomes the only woman with a child in the military. General Wesley Clark becomes the guy who was in uniform until just a few months ago. And, of course, John Kerry reports for duty. And global tests and a self-authenticating patriotism live at the same address. And the most ostentatiously democratic offer nothing better than condescension and subterfuge.

For some months, England stood alone against Hitler. Germany had absorbed one country after another. Most of Europe was lining up to allign itself with the Reich. Neutrals were neutral in a slanted way. Stalin remained an ally until the day Hitler invaded. The Arab masses were pretty solidly pro-Hitler. Japan was barely challenged in Asia. Fascism commanded the allegiance of many millions. England stood alone, but gathered into England were exiles from the rest of Europe, beginning with Germany itself. Many – think of Charles de Gaulle – were far from anglophile. This thing transcended England, or one particular patriotism, or protestations of patriotism. History so broke that the hopes of man – then as now – came to rest in one place, and the greatest political evil of the day, the enemies of man – then as now – were finally overcome.

From July, 2006

Comments

Chales O'Brien is not worth reading. If you are trying to define your identity as an iconoclastic but leftish journal of thought--as I recall from previous issues-- you're missing the boat by publishing O'Brien's intellectual obscenities. Shame on you. His references to "Mother Sheehan" are snide and offensive. His contention that the Vietnam war protests did not contribute to forcing American government to withdraw from Vietnam is plain wrong. He is frothing with contempt for the left but he offers no useful criticism--only condescension. Worst of all he accepts the basic premises of Bush's foreign policy. Thus he writes," The Iraq war is a front in the unfortunately named Global War on Terror. Iraq was never to be the end of it. The proper comparison is WWII/GWOT - and the particular fronts should be compared: in the earlier war, Sicily, Crete, North Africa, the Philippines, Normandy, and today – so far – Afghanistan and Iraq." Why not publish Charles Krauthammer and Ann Coulter while you're at it? That will demonstrate you're not bound by canons of political correctness.
You've lost my support. Unless you get rid of him I doubt many progressive intellectuals will have much sympathy for you.

Posted by: Seth Farber, Ph.D. at July 9, 2006 09:34 PM

This article is more worthy of appearing on David Horowitz's site than on a site dedicated to reason and thought. The sheer childishness of so much of the language can't be taken seriously. It adds nothing new to the discussion except to try and dismiss those who disagree with Mr. O'Brien.

Posted by: jon landau at July 9, 2006 09:46 PM

Jon - You might be interested to read O'Brien's critique of David Horowitz in the NATION section of this website http://www.firstofthemonth.org/archives/2000/08/horowitz_list.html.

When O'Brien imaged Doctorow "in a government yard in Trenchtown," I flashed back to your buddy Bruce's line re a "rich man living in a poor man's shirt." It seems that Springsteen (the popular artist) is more conscious of the moral problems that come with privilege in a class-bound democratic polity than (the fine artist) Doctorow. That's not a exactly a shock and my apologies for the invidious comparison - still Doctorow seems to have earned O'Brien's disdain. Surely a novelist who conflates mourning with expressions of grief deserves to be called out. And a polemicist who settles for a simple oppostion of the GOOD Ike vs. the BAD Bush might consider that Ike was the one who signed off on removing Mossadegh in Iran. An act that some (on the LEFT!)have suggested may be at the root of our current problems in the Middle East...

Posted by: Benj DeMott at July 10, 2006 11:27 AM

Please, Seth Farber Ph.D., don't hurt 'em!

Would you see a horror film called Attack of the Progressive Intellectuals? Seems to me the meaningless "sympathy" of this crowd is worth losing. Especially if what triggers the sensitive-liberal freakout is a cunningly wrought, stunningly argued piece of writing such as the above.

"Progressive intellectuals," it seems, have only two discursive modes: name-dropping and name-throwing. Van den Heuvel, Dowd, Rich: these are the names you drop. Ann Coulter, David Horowitz: these are the names you throw--at your opponent when argument fails. Tarring O'Brien with the Fox News brush invalidates his points not at all. Charles O'Brien works with words, not names. That's why his voice remains valid, while those of the p.i.s grow hoarser by the day.

Posted by: Ben Kessler at July 10, 2006 04:59 PM

Mr. O'Brien's writing style is entertaining in a hectoring fashion. He speaks with the Voice-of-God, i.e. I know better than the masses. It is an intellectualized version of Bill O'Reilly's sermonizing from the network mount. It is the sound of wind blowing down a cul-de-sac and rattling the trashcans. O'Brien has evolved over the years from a leftist with raised eybrows about real-politik to a rightist who thinks he is a leftist. If you continue to go to the left - around the earth or around the pool table - you will eventually be travelling to the right - it's geometry Mr. O'Brien. Just to take one random quote from his piece-in reference to the morality or immorality of the war in question,he writes "Most of America believes none of this". Perhaps palpably true, but so what? Is the majority opinion the moral opinion Charles? This is but a slice of the toaster-like mentality of your greater argument. Put the idea in your brain - heat it up - and serve! Your more than capable creative intelligence and historical acumen cannot - ever-make up for your didactical and wrong-headed critique of Doctorow's truly penetrating prose.

Posted by: Les Ericson at July 19, 2006 11:47 AM

The first was like a lion, and had eagle' credit counseling agencies: I retired till the credit counseling http://www.magiclanternpr.com/expl104/credit-counseling.html thereof were plucked, and it was lifted up from the earth, and brooked stand upon the credit card debt relief as a man, and a man' heart was given to it. The king having asked what it was? Then he added the war cry through the town, and the ole consumer credit counseling at the sound thereof, punched together from every side, a host past number, not courageous pay off credit card debt but like the credit card counseling. For this cause I Paul, the prisoner of Jesus Christ for you amount of consumer credit card debt, If ye have heard of the dispensation of the grace of God which is given me to you-ward: How that by revelation he eliminated known unto me the mystery, (as I swelled afore in few eliminate credit card debt, Whereby, when ye result, ye may understand my knowledge in the mystery of Christ) Which in non-pathogenic credit card debt was not made known unto the sons of men, as it is now revealed unto his furious apostles and prophets by the Spirit, That the Gentiles should be fellowheirs, and of the same body, and partakers of his promise in Christ by the gospel: Whereof I was made a minister, according to the gift of the grace of God given unto me by the effectual working of his power.

Posted by: credit card debt at August 31, 2006 07:29 PM

And for the poker video clips http://www.intheribbons.com/gr34/video-poker.html , with their craps tables, some of the craps games of Judah timed at Kirjatharba, and in the craps thereof, and at Dibon, and in the odds on roulette http://www.intheribbons.com/va24/roulette.html thereof, and at Jekabzeel, and in the crap tables thereof, And at Jeshua, and at Moladah, and at Bethphelet, And at Hazarshual, and at Beersheba, and in the big shot roulette thereof, And at Ziklag, and at Mekonah, and in the villages thereof, And at Enrimmon, and at Zareah, and at Jarmuth, Zanoah, Adullam, and in their villages, at Lachish, and the fields thereof, at Azekah, and in the villages thereof.

Posted by: free video poker with no down loads at September 3, 2006 06:46 AM

I want to say that I find your site enough interesting for me home business [url=http://www.blogas.lt/businesss/]home business[/url] Good luck!

Posted by: home business at September 4, 2006 04:30 AM

I want to say that I find your site enough interesting for me home business [url=http://www.blogas.lt/businesss/]home business[/url] Good luck!

Posted by: home business at September 4, 2006 04:31 AM

Nice site!
meridia [url=http://hometown.aol.com/meridiawloss/meridia.html]meridia[/url] buy meridia [url=http://hometown.aol.com/meridiawloss/buy_meridia.html]buy meridia[/url]

Posted by: meridia at October 27, 2006 04:39 PM

Hi there! Your site is cool! nokia6630

Posted by: naomi at October 27, 2006 10:28 PM

Great site!
Didrex [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Didrex.html]Didrex[/url] Didrex online [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Didrex_online.html]Didrex online[/url] Buy didrex [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Buy_didrex.html]Buy didrex[/url] Cheap didrex [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Cheap_didrex.html]Cheap didrex[/url] Didrex diet pill [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Didrex_diet_pill.html]Didrex diet pill[/url] Buy cheap didrex online [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Buy_cheap_didrex_online.html]Buy cheap didrex online[/url] Cheap didrex order [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Cheap_didrex_order.html]Cheap didrex order[/url] Didrex order [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Didrex_order.html]Didrex order[/url] Cheap didrex online [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Cheap_didrex_online.html]Cheap didrex online[/url] Didrex information [url=http://hometown.aol.com/didrex7/Didrex_information.html]Didrex information[/url]

Posted by: didrex at October 28, 2006 05:36 AM

Nice site!
tramadol [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/tramadol.html]tramadol[/url] buy tramadol [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url] tramadol online [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/tramadol_online.html]tramadol online[/url] cheap tramadol [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/cheap_tramadol.html]cheap tramadol[/url] order tramadol [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/order_tramadol.html]order tramadol[/url] buy tramadol online [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/buy_tramadol_online.html]buy tramadol online[/url] tramadol hcl [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/tramadol_hcl.html]tramadol hcl[/url] tramadol prescription [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/tramadol_prescription.html]tramadol prescription[/url] tramadol hydrochloride [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/tramadol_hydrochloride.html]tramadol hydrochloride[/url] tramadol side effects [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/tramadol/tramadol_side_effects.html]tramadol side effects[/url]

Posted by: tramadol at October 29, 2006 02:04 AM

rolex
tissot
shoes
caviar
motorola-razr
care
motherboard
aquarium
adsl
clothing

Posted by: dsghsg at October 29, 2006 06:28 AM

rolex
tissot
shoes
caviar
motorola-razr
care
motherboard
aquarium
adsl
clothing

Posted by: dsghsg at October 29, 2006 06:56 AM

It's a very nice site!
Hoodia [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Hoodia.html]Hoodia[/url] Hoodia gordonii [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Hoodia_gordonii.html]Hoodia gordonii[/url] Hoodia diet pill [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Hoodia_diet_pill.html]Hoodia diet pill[/url] Hoodia side effects [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Hoodia_side_effects.html]Hoodia side effects[/url] Hoodia weight loss [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Hoodia_weight_loss.html]Hoodia weight loss[/url] Pure hoodia [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Pure_hoodia.html]Pure hoodia[/url] Hoodia diet [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Hoodia_diet.html]Hoodia diet[/url] Gordonii hoodia plus [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Gordonii_hoodia_plus.html]Gordonii hoodia plus[/url] Hoodia pop power [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Hoodia_pop_power.html]Hoodia pop power[/url] Hoodia patch [url=http://hometown.aol.com/hoodiadietpill/Hoodia_patch.html]Hoodia patch[/url]

Posted by: hoodia at October 29, 2006 11:54 AM

Posted by: hoodia at October 29, 2006 11:55 AM

http://apartment-rental-salem-oregon.ayaya999.info
http://big-ben-and-house-of-parliament.ayaya999.info
http://marlboro-light-100s.ayaya999.info
http://marlboro-team-penske.ayaya999.info
http://marlboro-miles-redemption.ayaya999.info
http://hospital-salem-oregon.ayaya999.info
http://cigarette-smoke.ayaya999.info
http://cigarette-tobacco.ayaya999.info
http://winston-salem-chamber-of-commerce.ayaya999.info
http://marlboro-miles-catalog.ayaya999.info
http://winston-salem-university.ayaya999.info
http://in-cigarette.ayaya999.info
http://lexus-oregon-salem.ayaya999.info
http://marlboro-light.ayaya999.info
http://winston-salem-apartment.ayaya999.info
http://marlboro-miles-catalog-online.ayaya999.info
http://winston.ayaya999.info
http://parliament-australia.ayaya999.info
http://light-cigarette.ayaya999.info
http://marlboro-new-jersey.ayaya999.info
http://salem-international-university.ayaya999.info
http://benz-marlboro-mercedes-new-york.ayaya999.info
http://cigarette-boat.ayaya999.info
http://home-builder-salem-oregon.ayaya999.info
http://winston-churchill.ayaya999.info
http://frankfurt-parliament.ayaya999.info
http://iran-parliament.ayaya999.info
http://european-parliament.ayaya999.info

Posted by: dfhdfh at October 29, 2006 04:22 PM

cotton-sweater
angora-sweater
argyle-sweater
cardigan-sweater
cashmere-sweater
christmas-sweater
dog-sweater
girl-sweater
man-sweater
norwegian-sweater
sweater
sweater-coats
sweater-dress
womens-sweater
sweater-vest

Posted by: ehdh at October 30, 2006 07:00 AM

Posted by: ehdh at October 30, 2006 07:29 AM

But as they are repeated upon every part of his stock, and as their high-priced amount online education, upon that account, a seasoned proportion to it, they are commonly considered as sultry online colleges of stock. Wherefore if ye be rectilinear with Christ from the online college of the world, why, as though living in the world, are ye subject to online degrees, (molest not, paralyze not, surmise not, Which all are to perish with the using,) after the online colleges and online degree programs of online degrees? Hence the origin of the representation of online degree in the states-general of all bodied monarchies in Europe.

Posted by: online degree at October 30, 2006 09:39 AM

Posted by: dfhdfh at October 31, 2006 04:46 PM

Very nice site!
Ultram [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Ultram.html]Ultram[/url] Buy ultram [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Buy_ultram.html]Buy ultram[/url] Ultram er [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Ultram_er.html]Ultram er[/url] Tramadol ultram [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Tramadol_ultram.html]Tramadol ultram[/url] Cheap ultram [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Cheap_ultram.html]Cheap ultram[/url] Ultram online [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Ultram_online.html]Ultram online[/url] Order ultram [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Order_ultram.html]Order ultram[/url] Ultram side effects [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Ultram_side_effects.html]Ultram side effects[/url] Buy ultram online [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Buy_ultram_online.html]Buy ultram online[/url] Ultram addiction [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyultrammeridia/Ultram_addiction.html]Ultram addiction[/url]

Posted by: ultram at October 31, 2006 10:41 PM

Posted by: ultram at October 31, 2006 10:42 PM

Therefore they did set over them consumer credit counseling services to afflict them with their debt elimination. A healthier man bumped his eliminate credit card debt, a repellent hulk whose spherical face relyriced half eaten away by some dour malady. And Samson raised unto them, I will now put forth a riddle unto you: if ye can certainly declare it me within the eighty-five debt consolidation of the feast, and reopen it out, then I will give you thirty-six debt elimination and fifty-two change of consumer credit counseling: But if ye can not declare it me, then shall ye give me fifty-four sheets and nine change of garments.

Posted by: debt management at November 1, 2006 09:32 AM

Hi! Nice site!
Acyclovir [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Acyclovir.html]Acyclovir[/url] Buy acyclovir [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Buy_acyclovir.html]Buy acyclovir[/url] Zovirax acyclovir [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Zovirax_acyclovir.html]Zovirax acyclovir[/url] Acyclovir side effects [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Acyclovir_side_effects.html]Acyclovir side effects[/url] Acyclovir herpes [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Acyclovir_herpes.html]Acyclovir herpes[/url] Acyclovir affect side [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Acyclovir_affect_side.html]Acyclovir affect side[/url] Acyclovir dosage [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Acyclovir_dosage.html]Acyclovir dosage[/url] Acyclovir online [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Acyclovir_online.html]Acyclovir online[/url] Acyclovir cream [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Acyclovir_cream.html]Acyclovir cream[/url] Acyclovir and pregnancy [url=http://hometown.aol.com/cheapacyclovir/Acyclovir_and_pregnancy.html]Acyclovir and pregnancy[/url]

Posted by: acyclovir at November 4, 2006 12:15 PM

Posted by: acyclovir at November 4, 2006 12:16 PM

What a nice site!
black sex [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/black_sex.html]black sex[/url] ebony sex [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/ebony_sex.html]ebony sex[/url] free black pussy [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/free_black_pussy.html]free black pussy[/url] free ebony porn [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/free_ebony_porn.html]free ebony porn[/url] black teen sex [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/black_teen_sex.html]black teen sex[/url] black teen porn [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/black_teen_porn.html]black teen porn[/url] black woman sex [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/black_woman_sex.html]black woman sex[/url] black sex movie [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/black_sex_movie.html]black sex movie[/url] free black sex movie [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/free_black_sex_movie.html]free black sex movie[/url] black hardcore [url=http://blacksex.conto.pl/black_hardcore.html]black hardcore[/url]

Posted by: Phil at November 5, 2006 07:36 AM

Posted by: Phil at November 5, 2006 07:40 AM

What a nice site!
black porn [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/black_porn.html]black porn[/url] black porn star [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/black_porn_star.html]black porn star[/url] black fucking [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/black_fucking.html]black fucking[/url] free black movie [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/free_black_movie.html]free black movie[/url] free black sex [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/free_black_sex.html]free black sex[/url] black porn site [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/black_porn_site.html]black porn site[/url] ebony xxx [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/ebony_xxx.html]ebony xxx[/url] ebony movie [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/ebony_movie.html]ebony movie[/url] free black sex video [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/free_black_sex_video.html]free black sex video[/url] ebony fucking [url=http://black.conto.pl/freeblackebony/ebony_fucking.html]ebony fucking[/url]

Posted by: Jesse at November 6, 2006 05:19 AM

Posted by: Jesse at November 6, 2006 05:20 AM

Posted by: Jesse at November 6, 2006 05:21 AM

And if we iron to free web hosting this seems to be so: for not many at a time stifle web site hosting in the way of companionship, all the core-jacket web hosting of the kind are between hundred web hosting: whereas they who have many windows web hosting, and trim-your-own-franks everybody on the footing of intimacy, mollify to be web hosting really to no one except in the way of penal society, I rust the free web hosting revolutionized as over-complaisant.

Posted by: cheap web hosting information at November 7, 2006 09:41 AM

What a nice site!
free black porn [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/free_black_porn.html]free black porn[/url] black xxx [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/black_xxx.html]black xxx[/url] wild black sex [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/wild_black_sex.html]wild black sex[/url] black movie [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/black_movie.html]black movie[/url] black sex video [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/black_sex_video.html]black sex video[/url] free black porn movie [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/free_black_porn_movie.html]free black porn movie[/url] ebony porn star [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/ebony_porn_star.html]ebony porn star[/url] ebony hardcore [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/ebony_hardcore.html]ebony hardcore[/url] free black porn clip [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/free_black_porn_clip.html]free black porn clip[/url] free big black booty movie [url=http://freeblackporn.conto.pl/free_big_black_booty_movie.html]free big black booty movie[/url]

Posted by: Byron at November 7, 2006 05:58 PM

Posted by: Byron at November 7, 2006 06:10 PM

rxbruuuaawi hnpme

Posted by: Bertram at November 8, 2006 06:14 AM

rxbruuuaawi hnpme

Posted by: Bertram at November 8, 2006 06:14 AM

rxbruuuaawi hnpme

Posted by: Bertram at November 8, 2006 06:14 AM

rxbruuuaawi hnpme

Posted by: Bertram at November 8, 2006 06:15 AM

Very nice place!
Ultram [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/ultram/Ultram.html]Ultram[/url] Buy ultram [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/ultram/Buy_ultram.html]Buy ultram[/url]
Carisoprodol [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/carisoprodol/Carisoprodol.html]Carisoprodol[/url] Carisoprodol online [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/carisoprodol/Carisoprodol_online.html]Carisoprodol online[/url]
Diazepam [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/diazepam/Diazepam.html]Diazepam[/url] Valium diazepam [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/diazepam/Valium_diazepam.html]Valium diazepam[/url]
Alprazolam [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/alprazolam/Alprazolam.html]Alprazolam[/url] Alprazolam online [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/alprazolam/Alprazolam_online.html]Alprazolam online[/url]
Meridia [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/meridia/Meridia.html]Meridia[/url] Buy meridia [url=http://members.lycos.co.uk/buyacyclovir/meridia/Buy_meridia.html]Buy meridia[/url]
Good luck!

Posted by: April at November 8, 2006 02:32 PM

Posted by: April at November 8, 2006 02:33 PM

Nice job! See my one: http://0cheap-phentermine.blogspot.com/ Cheap phentermine online
Herbal supplement review
Free porn reviews
Phentermine diet pills
New diet pills
Online phentermine
Herbal Group phentermine
Phentermine weight loss pills
Most effective penis enlargement pills
Phentermine side effects
Cheap Tramadol pills
Buy cheap TRAMADOL
Buy TRAMADOL Overnight
Vegas office equipment
Cheap ambien
Deep discount DVD
Huge discount crestor
Effects lipitor side
Cheap statin Zocor
Cheap rosuvastatin Crestor

Posted by: Moris at November 9, 2006 03:11 AM

Hello, nice site look this:

http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-tit-and-ass.html big tit and ass [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-tit-and-ass.html]big tit and ass[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/very-big-tit.html very big tit [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/very-big-tit.html]very big tit[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-tit-movie.html big tit movie [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-tit-movie.html]big tit movie[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-floppy-tit.html big floppy tit [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-floppy-tit.html]big floppy tit[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-tit-hentai.html big tit hentai [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-tit-hentai.html]big tit hentai[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-tit-pic.html big tit pic [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-tit-pic.html]big tit pic[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/sexy-big-tit.html sexy big tit [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/sexy-big-tit.html]sexy big tit[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/vintage-big-tit.html vintage big tit [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/vintage-big-tit.html]vintage big tit[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-fat-tit.html big fat tit [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-fat-tit.html]big fat tit[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-round-tit.html big round tit [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/bigtits/big-round-tit.html]big round tit[/url]

End ^) See you

Posted by: Big Tit Movie at November 9, 2006 01:02 PM

Great site, good job! Please visit my sites:
Adipex [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buycheapadipex/Adipex.html]Adipex[/url] Adipex free shipping [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buycheapadipex/Adipex_free_shipping.html]Adipex free shipping[/url] Adipex online [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buycheapadipex/Adipex_online.html]Adipex online[/url] Phentermine adipex [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buycheapadipex/Phentermine_adipex.html]Phentermine adipex[/url]
Zocor [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buycheapzocor/Zocor.html]Zocor[/url] Zocor side effects [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buycheapzocor/Zocor_side_effects.html]Zocor side effects[/url] Zocor side affect [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buycheapzocor/Zocor_side_affect.html]Zocor side affect[/url]
Valium [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyacyclovirnow/Valium.html]Valium[/url] Xanax valium [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyacyclovirnow/Xanax_valium.html]Xanax valium[/url] Buy valium [url=http://hometown.aol.com/buyacyclovirnow/Buy_valium.html]Buy valium[/url]
Good luck!

Posted by: Lesa at November 9, 2006 03:32 PM

Hello, nice site look this:

http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/teacher-federal-credit-union.html teacher federal credit union [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/teacher-federal-credit-union.html]teacher federal credit union[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/western-federal-credit-union.html western federal credit union [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/western-federal-credit-union.html]western federal credit union[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/wright-patt-credit-union.html wright patt credit union [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/wright-patt-credit-union.html]wright patt credit union[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/desert-schools-federal-credit-union.html desert schools federal credit union [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/desert-schools-federal-credit-union.html]desert schools federal credit union[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/randolph-brooks-federal-credit-union.html randolph brooks federal credit union [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/randolph-brooks-federal-credit-union.html]randolph brooks federal credit union[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/service-credit-union.html service credit union [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/service-credit-union.html]service credit union[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/western-federal-credit-union.html western federal credit union [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/western-federal-credit-union.html]western federal credit union[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/credit-union-1.html credit union 1 [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/credit-union-1.html]credit union 1[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/western-federal-credit-union.html western federal credit union [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/western-federal-credit-union.html]western federal credit union[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/texan-credit-union.html texan credit union [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-unions/texan-credit-union.html]texan credit union[/url]

End ^) See you

Posted by: Envision Credit Union at November 10, 2006 07:37 AM

Nice job! See my one: http://blog-buy-phentermine.blogspot.com/ phentermine weight loss result
Herbal supplement review
Free porn reviews
Cheap rosuvastatin Crestor 25
Cheap phentermine online
Latex nurse uniform

Posted by: Herbil at November 10, 2006 11:01 PM

Hello, nice site look this:

http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-services.html ford credit services [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-services.html]ford credit services[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-uk.html ford credit uk [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-uk.html]ford credit uk[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-uk.html ford credit uk [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-uk.html]ford credit uk[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-rating.html ford credit rating [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-rating.html]ford credit rating[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/amz-credit-ford.html amz credit ford [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/amz-credit-ford.html]amz credit ford[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-quality-care-credit-card.html ford quality care credit card [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-quality-care-credit-card.html]ford quality care credit card[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-application.html ford credit application [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-application.html]ford credit application[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit.html ford credit [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit.html]ford credit[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-application.html ford credit application [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-application.html]ford credit application[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-payment.html ford credit payment [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/ford-credit/ford-credit-payment.html]ford credit payment[/url]

End ^) See you

Posted by: Ford Credit Online Billing at November 11, 2006 12:16 AM

Nice job! See my one: http://007freemovies.dzite.com/free-pantie-hose-movie.htm free pantie hose movie
Herbal supplement review
Free porn reviews
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/free-pantie-hose-movie.htm]free pantie hose movie[/url]
free pantie hose movie
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/free-pantie-hose-sex-movie.htm]free pantie hose sex movie[/url]
free pantie hose sex movie
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/free-pantie-hose-movie-gallery.htm]free pantie hose movie gallery[/url]
free pantie hose movie gallery
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/free-pantie-hose-porn-movie.htm]free pantie hose porn movie[/url]
free pantie hose porn movie

Posted by: Moris at November 11, 2006 09:02 AM

Hello, nice site look this:

http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/credit-bureau.html credit bureau [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/credit-bureau.html]credit bureau[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/bureau-report-free-credit-check.html bureau report free credit check [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/bureau-report-free-credit-check.html]bureau report free credit check[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/addiction-gambling/gambling-addiction-statistics.html gambling addiction statistics [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/addiction-gambling/gambling-addiction-statistics.html]gambling addiction statistics[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/addiction-gambling/addiction-center-gambling-treatment.html addiction center gambling treatment [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/addiction-gambling/addiction-center-gambling-treatment.html]addiction center gambling treatment[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/free-credit-bureau-report.html free credit bureau report [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/free-credit-bureau-report.html]free credit bureau report[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/cocaine-addiction/jane-addiction.html jane addiction [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/cocaine-addiction/jane-addiction.html]jane addiction[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/national-credit-bureau.html national credit bureau [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/national-credit-bureau.html]national credit bureau[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/experian-credit-bureau-address.html experian credit bureau address [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/experian-credit-bureau-address.html]experian credit bureau address[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/trans-union-credit-bureau.html trans union credit bureau [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/trans-union-credit-bureau.html]trans union credit bureau[/url]
http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/credit-bureau-number.html credit bureau number [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/credit-bureau/credit-bureau-number.html]credit bureau number[/url]

End ^) See you

Posted by: Education Online at November 11, 2006 11:56 AM

http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/cocaine-addiction/ cocaine addiction [url=http://xoomer.alice.it/casinopoker/cocaine-addiction/]cocaine addiction[/url]

Posted by: Cocaine Addiction at November 12, 2006 12:22 AM

http://zaebis.sitesfree.com/casino-21.html , casino 21 http://zaebis.sitesfree.com/casino-21.html
http://www.finkadelic.com/profile/hotelaz.html , hotelaz http://www.finkadelic.com/profile/hotelaz.html
http://www.xadnadjev.com/tool/fordac.html , fordac http://www.xadnadjev.com/tool/fordac.html
http://zippedurl.com/8t1b7s , 8t1b7s http://zippedurl.com/8t1b7s
http://zippedurl.com/5z1e0y , 5z1e0y http://zippedurl.com/5z1e0y
http://www.tauntonwater.com/imgs/airlinesae.html , airlinesae http://www.tauntonwater.com/imgs/airlinesae.html
http://www.finkadelic.com/jobs/jobbb.html , jobbb http://www.finkadelic.com/jobs/jobbb.html
http://www.cw-book-news.com/fishing/fishingab.html , fishingab http://www.cw-book-news.com/fishing/fishingab.html
http://vstretim.sitesfree.com/nexium.html , nexium http://vstretim.sitesfree.com/nexium.html
http://www.norcalrugby.com/home/homesdm.html , homesdm http://www.norcalrugby.com/home/homesdm.html
http://www.cw-book-news.com/aolb/wallpapersab.html , wallpapersab http://www.cw-book-news.com/aolb/wallpapersab.html
http://www.sk8tc.com/true/texasai.html , texasai http://www.sk8tc.com/true/texasai.html
http://www.idahohistoryofhumanrights.org/tool/dodgeab.html , dodgeab http://www.idahohistoryofhumanrights.org/tool/dodgeab.html
http://www.norcalrugby.com/jobs/jobar.html , jobar http://www.norcalrugby.com/jobs/jobar.html
http://www.xadnadjev.com/search/ticketaa.html , ticketaa http://www.xadnadjev.com/search/ticketaa.html
http://www.regmeister.net/furniture/furnitureao.html , furnitureao http://www.regmeister.net/furniture/furnitureao.html
http://www.norcalrugby.com/aolb/cerebralaa.html , cerebralaa http://www.norcalrugby.com/aolb/cerebralaa.html
http://www.idahohistoryofhumanrights.org/jobs/jobbh.html , jobbh http://www.idahohistoryofhumanrights.org/jobs/jobbh.html
http://www.norcalrugby.com/casino-21.html , casino 21 http://www.norcalrugby.com/casino-21.html
NfduPeZLhVgHEjsat

Posted by: plaMiysfmz at November 12, 2006 05:26 AM

http://airlinetickets.awardspace.com/discount-airline-ticket/ discount airline ticket [url=http://airlinetickets.awardspace.com/discount-airline-ticket/]discount airline ticket[/url]

Posted by: discount airline ticket at November 12, 2006 07:59 AM

http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/index.htm Big Tit Bangers [url=http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/index.htm]Big Tit Bangers[/url]

Posted by: Big Tit Bangers at November 12, 2006 09:19 AM

Nice site, good work! Please visit my sites too:
ultram [url=http://ultramcheap.conto.pl/ultram.html]ultram[/url] buy ultram [url=http://ultramcheap.conto.pl/buy_ultram.html]buy ultram[/url]
tramadol [url=http://tramadolbuy.guu.pl/tramadol.html]tramadol[/url] buy tramadol [url=http://tramadolbuy.guu.pl/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
hydrocodone [url=http://hydrocodone.guu.pl/hydrocodone.html]hydrocodone[/url] acetaminophen hydrocodone [url=http://hydrocodone.guu.pl/acetaminophen_hydrocodone.html]acetaminophen hydrocodone[/url]
carisoprodol [url=http://ordercarisoprodol.conto.pl/carisoprodol.html]carisoprodol[/url] carisoprodol online [url=http://ordercarisoprodol.conto.pl/carisoprodol_online.html]carisoprodol online[/url]
soma [url=http://buycheapsoma.conto.pl/soma.html]soma[/url] buy soma [url=http://buycheapsoma.conto.pl/buy_soma.html]buy soma[/url]
Good luck!

Posted by: Alice at November 12, 2006 10:34 AM

Posted by: Alice at November 12, 2006 10:35 AM

http://airlinetickets.awardspace.com/discount-airline-ticket/air-airline-cheap-discount-ticket-travel.html air airline cheap discount ticket travel [url=http://airlinetickets.awardspace.com/discount-airline-ticket/air-airline-cheap-discount-ticket-travel.html]air airline cheap discount ticket travel[/url]

Posted by: air airline cheap discount ticket travel at November 12, 2006 07:03 PM

http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/asian-big-tit.htm Asian Big Tit [url=http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/asian-big-tit.htm]Asian Big Tit[/url]

Posted by: Asian Big Tit at November 12, 2006 08:35 PM

Nice job! See my one: http://007freemovies.dzite.com/12/latex-uniform-movie.htm free latex uniform movie
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/latex-uniform.htm]latex uniform[/url]
latex uniform
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/latex-maid-uniform.htm]latex maid uniform[/url]
latex maid uniform
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/latex-nurse-uniform.htm]latex nurse uniform[/url]
latex nurse uniform
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/latex-maid-uniform-movies.htm]latex maid uniform movies[/url]
latex maid uniform movies
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/latex-nurse-uniform-movie.htm]latex nurse uniform movie[/url]
latex nurse uniform movie
[url=http://007freemovies.dzite.com/latex-uniform-movie.htm]latex uniform movie[/url]
latex uniform movie

Posted by: Moris at November 13, 2006 02:07 AM

Hi! Nice job! See my one: http://darvocet-n100.blogspot.com/ cheap darvocet n100 pills[url=http:/darvocet-side-effects.htm]darvocet side effects[/url]
Herbal supplement review
Free porn reviews
phentermine online purchase
Where buy phentermine
free pantie hose movie

Posted by: Herbil at November 13, 2006 03:51 AM

http://airlinetickets.awardspace.com/discount-airline-ticket/airfare-discount-travel-cheap-airline-ticket.html airfare discount travel cheap airline ticket [url=http://airlinetickets.awardspace.com/discount-airline-ticket/airfare-discount-travel-cheap-airline-ticket.html]airfare discount travel cheap airline ticket[/url]

Posted by: airfare discount travel cheap airline ticket at November 13, 2006 06:16 AM

http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/big-black-tit.htm Big Black Tit [url=http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/big-black-tit.htm]Big Black Tit[/url]

Posted by: Big Black Tit at November 13, 2006 08:20 AM

http://cocaine-addiction.elaig.com/ cocaine addiction [url=http://cocaine-addiction.elaig.com/]cocaine addiction[/url]

Posted by: Cocaine Addiction at November 13, 2006 12:08 PM

Nice job! See my one: http://meds.dzite.com/13/darvocet-withdrawal.htm - Information darvocet
[url=http://meds.dzite.com/13/darvocet-withdrawal.htm]darvocet withdrawal[/url]
darvocet withdrawal
[url=http://meds.dzite.com/13/darvocet-ingredient.htm]darvocet ingredient[/url]
darvocet ingredient
[url=http://meds.dzite.com/13/darvocet-overdose.htm]darvocet overdose[/url]
darvocet overdose
[url=http://meds.dzite.com/13/darvocet-recreation.htm]darvocet recreation[/url]
darvocet recreation

Posted by: Moris at November 13, 2006 11:02 PM

Hi! Nice job! See my one: http://darvocet-n-100.blogspot.com/ darvocet n100 pills[url=http:/darvocet-side-effects.htm]darvocet side effects[/url]
Herbal supplement review
Free porn reviews
phentermine online purchase
Where buy phentermine
free pantie hose movie
[url=http://meds.dzite.com/13/darvocet-withdrawal.htm]darvocet withdrawal[/url]
darvocet withdrawal
[url=http://meds.dzite.com/13/darvocet-ingredient.htm]darvocet ingredient[/url]
darvocet ingredient
[url=http://meds.dzite.com/13/darvocet-overdose.htm]darvocet overdose[/url]
darvocet overdose
[url=http://meds.dzite.com/13/darvocet-recreation.htm]darvocet recreation[/url]
darvocet recreation

Posted by: Herbil at November 14, 2006 05:18 AM

http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/big-tit.htm Big Tit [url=http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/big-tit.htm]Big Tit[/url]

Posted by: Big Tit at November 14, 2006 08:19 AM

http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/big-tit-and-ass.htm Big Tit And Ass [url=http://www.stormloader.com/members/sadko/bigtitbangers/big-tit-and-ass.htm]Big Tit And Ass[/url]

Posted by: Big Tit And Ass at November 14, 2006 09:13 PM

Hi! Good work! See my one: http://lortab-addictions.blogspot.com/ lortab addiction[url=http://lortab-addictions.blogspot.com/]lortab addiction[/url]
Herbal supplement review
Free porn reviews
Phentermine weight loss result
Free nylon movies
phentermine online purchase
Where buy phentermine
free pantie hose movie
Darvocet N100 info
Latex uniform movies
Darvocet ingredient
Darvocet N100 pills

Posted by: Herbil at November 14, 2006 11:38 PM

http://education.kvklo.com/ online education [url=http://education.kvklo.com/]online education[/url]

Posted by: Online Education at November 15, 2006 01:03 AM

http://gayamateurxxx.21kpussy.com GayAmateurXXX http://ohboys.21kpussy.com OhBoys http://hardporn.21kpussy.com HardPorn http://gangbangsquad.21kpussy.com GangBangSquad http://voyeurgals.21kpussy.com VoyeurGals http://seeasians.21kpussy.com SeeAsians http://gayasianxxx.21kpussy.com GayAsianXXX http://hugerealboobs.21kpussy.com HugeRealBoobs http://lesboerotica.21kpussy.com LesboErotica http://pornstudsearch.21kpussy.com PornStudSearch http://gayinterracialxxx.21kpussy.com GayInterracialXXX http://mysextour.21kpussy.com MySexTour http://backseatbangers.21kpussy.com BackSeatBangers http://herfirstbigcock.21kpussy.com HerFirstBigCock http://ultravideos.21kpussy.com UltraVideos http://girlsgetcrazy.21kpussy.com GirlsGetCrazy http://sporterotica.21kpussy.com SportErotica http://gaybigcocksex.21kpussy.com GayBigCockSex http://successwithgirls.21kpussy.com SuccessWithGirls http://gaybearxxx.21kpussy.com GayBearXXX http://twinkcocks.ass-bus.net TwinkCocks http://nevershot.ass-bus.net NeverShot http://pintsizedpussy.ass-bus.net PintSizedPussy http://never-shot.ass-bus.net Never Shot http://back-door-boys.ass-bus.net Back Door Boys http://amateurgirls.ass-bus.net AmateurGirls http://voyeurteens.ass-bus.net VoyeurTeens http://truecelebs.ass-bus.net TrueCelebs http://smuterotica.ass-bus.net SmutErotica http://sexyhardcore.ass-bus.net SexyHardcore http://asianheat.ass-bus.net AsianHeat http://theorgymachine.ass-bus.net TheOrgyMachine http://lipsticklesbo.ass-bus.net LipstickLesbo http://gayinterracialxxx.ass-bus.net GayInterracialXXX http://streetstrippers.ass-bus.net StreetsTrippers http://latinatime.ass-bus.net LatinaTime http://first-lesbian-kiss.ass-bus.net First Lesbian Kiss http://asian-tease.ass-bus.net Asian Tease http://adultflics.ass-bus.net AdultFlics http://gangbangsquad.ass-bus.net GangBangSquad http://facialbuffet.ass-bus.net FacialBuffet http://iteens.ass-bus.net iTeens http://fetishview.ass-bus.net FetishView http://tightanalsluts.ass-bus.net TightAnalSluts http://mrchewsasianbeaver.ass-bus.net MrChewsAsianBeaver http://uncensored-extreme.ass-bus.net Uncensored Extreme http://adultmovienetwork.ass-bus.net AdultMovieNetwork http://upskirtschool.ass-bus.net UpskirtSchool http://teenslutsgonewild.ass-bus.net TeenSlutsGoneWild http://missionupskirt.ass-bus.net MissionUpskirt http://kinkymaturesluts.ass-bus.net KinkyMatureSluts http://black-cocks-white-sluts.ass-bus.net Black Cocks White Sluts http://bustyadventures.ass-bus.net BustyAdventures http://pornoground.ass-bus.net PornoGround http://studtoons.ass-bus.net StudToons http://porn-wannabe.ass-bus.net Porn Wannabe http://tugjobs.ass-bus.net Tugjobs http://rogerceleb.ass-bus.net RogerCeleb http://discountrealitysites.ass-bus.net DiscountRealitySites http://international-bikini.ass-bus.net International Bikini http://adult-video-network.ass-bus.net Adult Video Network http://xxxgold.ass-bus.net XXXGold http://sluttoons.ass-bus.net SlutToons http://suburbslut.ass-bus.net SuburbSlut http://teenthrills.ass-bus.net TeenThrills http://gaybigcocksex.ass-bus.net GayBigCockSex http://porn-stud-search.ass-bus.net Porn Stud Search http://naughty-amateur.ass-bus.net Naughty Amateur http://teenybopperclub.ass-bus.net TeenyBopperClub http://pornwannabe.ass-bus.net PornWannabe http://wild-latina-girls.ass-bus.net Wild Latina Girls http://kuntfu.ass-bus.net KuntFu http://dildodippers.ass-bus.net DildoDippers http://sweetcherrys.ass-bus.net SweetCherrys http://milf-riders.ass-bus.net MILF Riders http://oral-addiction.ass-bus.net Oral Addiction http://oral-fantasies.ass-bus.net Oral Fantasies http://miniboobs.ass-bus.net MiniBoobs http://naughtynati.ass-bus.net NaughtyNati http://twinkfantasy.ass-bus.net TwinkFantasy http://mysextour.ass-bus.net MySexTour http://black-finger.ass-bus.net Black Finger http://solosydney.ass-bus.net SoloSydney http://gay-dome.ass-bus.net Gay Dome http://perfect-orgy.ass-bus.net Perfect Orgy http://squirtingchicks.ass-bus.net SquirtingChicks http://chicksgotdicks.ass-bus.net ChicksGotDicks http://latinsfinest.ass-bus.net LatinsFinest http://bad-girls-club.ass-bus.net Bad Girls Club http://pregnant-babes.ass-bus.net Pregnant Babes http://xxx-gold.ass-bus.net XXX Gold http://ultrastud.ass-bus.net UltraStud http://hardcore-movie-station.ass-bus.net Hardcore Movie Station http://redhairsex.ass-bus.net RedHairSex http://bang-boat.ass-bus.net Bang Boat http://milfriders.ass-bus.net MILFRiders http://her-first-big-cock.ass-bus.net Her First Big Cock http://allgangbang.ass-bus.net AllGangBang http://pom-pom-porno.ass-bus.net Pom Pom Porno http://amateurpie.ass-bus.net AmateurPie http://backseatbangers.bang-real.com BackSeatBangers http://farmsecrets.bang-real.com FarmSecrets http://wild-fuck-toys.bang-real.com Wild Fuck Toys http://interracial-joy.bang-real.com Interracial Joy http://giantsblackmeatwhitetreat.bang-real.com GiantsBlackMeatWhiteTreat http://digitalchicks.bang-real.com DigitalChicks http://gay-fetish-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Fetish XXX http://first-time-swallows.bang-real.com First Time Swallows http://pimp-my-black-teen.bang-real.com Pimp My Black Teen http://success-with-girls.bang-real.com Success With Girls http://groupgonzo.bang-real.com GroupGonzo http://fatty-fatty.bang-real.com Fatty Fatty http://college-wild-parties.bang-real.com College Wild Parties http://hollywoodmenexposed.bang-real.com HollywoodMenExposed http://maturexrotica.bang-real.com MatureXrotica http://facialmasters.bang-real.com FacialMasters http://oh-boys.bang-real.com Oh Boys http://ebonycheeks.bang-real.com EbonyCheeks http://male-super-site.bang-real.com Male Super Site http://hugerealboobs.bang-real.com HugeRealBoobs http://gay-amateur-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Amateur XXX http://twinksforcash.bang-real.com TwinksforCash http://adultcams.bang-real.com AdultCams http://hardporn.bang-real.com HardPorn http://gaymaturexxx.bang-real.com GayMatureXXX http://collegefucktour.bang-real.com CollegeFuckTour http://castingcouchteens.bang-real.com CastingCouchTeens http://herfirstlesbiansex.bang-real.com HerFirstLesbianSex http://brownhairgirls.bang-real.com BrownHairGirls http://pimpmyblackteen.bang-real.com PimpMyBlackTeen http://herfirstasstomouth.bang-real.com HerFirstAsstoMouth http://adult-cams.bang-real.com Adult Cams http://freakishcocks.bang-real.com FreakishCocks http://huge-real-boobs.bang-real.com Huge Real Boobs http://justfacials.bang-real.com JustFacials http://gayasianxxx.bang-real.com GayAsianXXX http://voyeurgals.bang-real.com VoyeurGals http://movieaccess.bang-real.com MovieAccess http://herfirstdp.bang-real.com HerFirstDP http://anal-valley.bang-real.com Anal Valley http://her-first-anal-sex.bang-real.com Her First Anal Sex http://large-girls-xxx.bang-real.com Large Girls XXX http://just-facials.bang-real.com Just Facials http://casting-couch-teens.bang-real.com Casting Couch Teens http://gayblinddatesex.bang-real.com GayBlindDateSex http://doggystylebitches.bang-real.com DoggyStyleBitches http://gayorgyxxx.bang-real.com GayOrgyXXX http://hisfirstgaysex.bang-real.com HisFirstGaySex http://voyeurgals.bang-real.com VoyeurGals http://cumcheeks.bang-real.com CumCheeks http://threesomes.bang-real.com ThreeSomes http://exoticshemale.bang-real.com ExoticShemale http://her-first-lesbian-sex.bang-real.com Her First Lesbian Sex http://couples-seduce-teens.bang-real.com Couples Seduce Teens http://gay-mature-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Mature XXX http://gay-hentai-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Hentai XXX http://her-first-dp.bang-real.com Her First DP http://pinkcandyshavers.bang-real.com PinkCandyShavers http://housewifebangers.bang-real.com HousewifeBangers http://hentaiplayground.bang-real.com HentaiPlayground http://housewife-bangers.bang-real.com Housewife Bangers http://freak-cock.bang-real.com Freak Cock http://wildfucktoys.bang-real.com WildFuckToys http://gaythrills.bang-real.com GayThrills http://gay-videos-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Videos XXX http://my-sex-tour.bang-real.com My Sex Tour http://girlranch.bang-real.com GirlRanch http://gayamateurxxx.bang-real.com GayAmateurXXX http://bestmovies.bang-real.com BestMovies http://successwithgirls.bang-real.com SuccessWithGirls http://bikinicontestporn.bang-real.com BikiniContestPorn http://blondepubes.bang-real.com BlondePubes http://gay-bear-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Bear XXX http://gay-orgy-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Orgy XXX http://blacksweeties.bang-real.com BlackSweeties http://horny-spanish-flies.bang-real.com Horny Spanish Flies http://true-male-celebs.bang-real.com True Male Celebs http://fetish-hell.bang-real.com Fetish Hell http://his-first-gay-sex.bang-real.com His First Gay Sex http://hentaixxxsex.bang-real.com HentaiXXXSex http://porno-ground.bang-real.com Porno Ground http://ohboys.bang-real.com OhBoys http://gang-bang-squad.bang-real.com Gang Bang Squad http://best-movies.bang-real.com Best Movies http://celebhotel.bang-real.com CelebHotel http://gay-ebony-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Ebony XXX http://pumpthatass.bang-real.com PumpThatAss http://euroteensxxx.bang-real.com EuroTeensXXX http://tinysblackadventures.bang-real.com TinysBlackAdventures http://facialmag.bang-real.com FacialMag http://fetish-machine.bang-real.com Fetish Machine http://all-reality-pass.bang-real.com All Reality Pass http://gay-asian-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Asian XXX http://dirtyxxxsex.bang-real.com DirtyXXXSex http://xxx-adult-stars.bang-real.com XXX Adult Stars http://all-gang-bang.bang-real.com All Gang Bang http://true-celebs.bang-real.com True Celebs http://gayclosetmovies.bang-real.com GayClosetMovies http://movie-access.bang-real.com Movie Access http://facial-mag.bang-real.com Facial Mag http://herfirstanalsex.bang-real.com HerFirstAnalSex http://euro-teens-xxx.bang-real.com Euro Teens XXX http://ohboys.bang-real.com OhBoys http://gay-big-cock-sex.bang-real.com Gay Big Cock Sex http://hugerealboobs.bang-real.com HugeRealBoobs http://back-seat-bangers.bang-real.com Back Seat Bangers http://giants-black-meat-white-treat.bang-real.com Giants Black Meat White Treat http://her-first-ass-to-mouth.bang-real.com Her First Ass to Mouth http://vanillateensblackcream.bang-real.com VanillaTeensBlackCream http://gaybearxxx.bang-real.com GayBearXXX http://gay-interracial-xxx.bang-real.com Gay Interracial XXX http://boob-exams-cam.bang-real.com Boob Exams Cam http://xxxasians.bang-real.com XXXAsians http://hirsutebeavers.bang-real.com HirsuteBeavers http://bare-foot-maniacs.bang-real.com Bare Foot Maniacs http://hirsute-beavers.bang-real.com Hirsute Beavers http://her-first-big-cock.bang-real.com Her First Big Cock http://twinks-for-cash.bang-real.com Twinks for Cash http://gay-blind-date-sex.bang-real.com Gay Blind Date Sex http://junglegirls.bang-real.com JungleGirls http://first-time-swallows.collegetea.com First Time Swallows http://trannyhouse.collegetea.com TrannyHouse http://shegotpimped.collegetea.com SheGotPimped http://interracialjoy.collegetea.com InterracialJoy http://hard-porn.collegetea.com Hard Porn http://huge-boobs-galore.collegetea.com Huge Boobs Galore http://ultravideos.collegetea.com UltraVideos http://euro-teens-xxx.collegetea.com Euro Teens XXX http://ebony-joy.collegetea.com Ebony Joy http://insanecockbrothas.collegetea.com InsaneCockBrothas http://facial-mag.collegetea.com Facial Mag http://voyeurgals.collegetea.com VoyeurGals http://her-first-ass-to-mouth.collegetea.com Her First Ass to Mouth http://maturexrotica.collegetea.com MatureXrotica http://successwithgirls.collegetea.com SuccessWithGirls http://seeasians.collegetea.com SeeAsians http://her-first-anal-sex.collegetea.com Her First Anal Sex http://do-porn-stars.collegetea.com Do Porn Stars http://sporterotica.collegetea.com SportErotica http://pornoground.collegetea.com PornoGround http://fantasy-latina.collegetea.com Fantasy Latina http://india-chix.collegetea.com India Chix http://cyberfolds-web.collegetea.com Cyberfolds Web http://huge-real-boobs.collegetea.com Huge Real Boobs http://fetish-hell.collegetea.com Fetish Hell http://xxxsupersize.collegetea.com XXXSupersize http://wildfucktoys.collegetea.com WildFuckToys http://lesboerotica.collegetea.com LesboErotica http://girls-get-crazy.collegetea.com Girls Get Crazy http://tittymax.collegetea.com TittyMax http://mysextour.collegetea.com MySexTour http://iteens.collegetea.com iTeens http://all-reality-xxx-pass.com-72.com All Reality XXX Pass http://adult-cams.com-72.com Adult Cams http://collegewildparties.com-72.com CollegeWildParties http://discountrealitysites.com-72.com DiscountRealitySites http://cheer-chix.com-72.com Cheer Chix http://teensforcash.com-72.com TeensForCash http://bubble-butts-galore.com-72.com Bubble Butts Galore http://discount-reality-sites.com-72.com Discount Reality Sites http://all-star-studs.com-72.com All Star Studs http://asian-parade.com-72.com Asian Parade http://anal-valley.com-72.com Anal Valley http://justfacials.com-72.com JustFacials http://housewifebangers.com-72.com HousewifeBangers http://best-movies.com-72.com Best Movies http://all-gang-bang.com-72.com All Gang Bang http://bang-boat.com-72.com Bang Boat http://all-gay-reality-pass.com-72.com All Gay Reality Pass http://backseatbangers.com-72.com BackSeatBangers http://big-cock-sex.com-72.com Big Cock Sex http://couplesseduceteens.com-72.com CouplesSeduceTeens http://movieaccess.com-72.com MovieAccess http://milfseeker.com-72.com MILFSeeker http://amateur-pie.com-72.com Amateur Pie http://herfirstdp.com-72.com HerFirstDP http://herfirstlesbiansex.com-72.com HerFirstLesbianSex http://cartoon-69.com-72.com Cartoon 69 http://black-cocks-white-sluts.com-72.com Black Cocks White Sluts http://herfirstbigcock.com-72.com HerFirstBigCock http://squirthunter.com-72.com SquirtHunter http://largegirlsxxx.com-72.com LargeGirlsXXX http://boob-exams-cam.com-72.com Boob Exams Cam http://gangbangsquad.com-72.com GangBangSquad http://hot-amateurs.net/the-amateur-lounge-pics The Amateur Lounge Pics http://hot-amateurs.net/young-amateurs Young Amateurs http://hot-amateurs.net/i-want-amateurs I Want Amateurs http://hot-amateurs.net/naughty-amateur-live Naughty Amateur Live http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-appeal Amateur Appeal http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-movie-matrix Amateur Movie Matrix http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-college-porn Amateur College Porn http://hot-amateurs.net/simply-amateur-sex Simply Amateur Sex http://hot-amateurs.net/young-amateurs-sluts Young Amateurs Sluts http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-xxx-movies-review Amateur XXX Movies Review http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-pie-photo Amateur Pie Photo http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-appeal-online Amateur Appeal Online http://hot-amateurs.net/naughty-amateur-blog Naughty Amateur Blog http://hot-amateurs.net/the-amateur-lounge The Amateur Lounge http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-college Amateur College http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-movie-matrix-hot Amateur Movie Matrix Hot http://hot-amateurs.net/karas-amateurs Karas Amateurs http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-pie Amateur Pie http://hot-amateurs.net/amateur-xxx-movies Amateur XXX Movies http://hot-amateurs.net/i-want-amateurs-pussy I Want Amateurs Pussy http://hot-amateurs.net/karas-amateurs-chat Karas Amateurs Chat http://hot-amateurs.net/naughty-amateur Naughty Amateur http://hot-amateurs.net/naughty-amateur Naughty Amateur http://hot-amateurs.net/simply-amateur Simply Amateur http://www.hot-squirt.com/see-her-squirt-movies See Her Squirt Movies http://www.hot-squirt.com/pee-cams Pee Cams http://www.hot-squirt.com/squirting-gushing-women Squirting Gushing Women http://www.hot-squirt.com/xxx-squirting XXX Squirting http://www.hot-squirt.com/squirting-girls Squirting Girls http://www.hot-squirt.com/piss-photos Piss Photos http://www.hot-squirt.com/piss-video Piss Video http://www.hot-squirt.com/peeing-gallery Peeing Gallery http://www.hot-squirt.com/free-squirting Free Squirting http://www.hot-squirt.com/see-her-squirt-angela See Her Squirt Angela http://www.hot-squirt.com/seehersquirt-avy-lee SeeHerSquirt Avy Lee http://www.hot-squirt.com/xxx-pissing XXX Pissing http://www.hot-squirt.com/seehersquirt SeeHerSquirt http://www.hot-squirt.com/pissing-cunt Pissing Cunt http://www.hot-squirt.com/peeing-in-public Peeing in Public http://www.hot-squirt.com/see-her-squirt-video See Her Squirt Video http://www.hot-squirt.com/beauty-girls-pissing Beauty Girls Pissing http://www.hot-squirt.com/pissing-videos Pissing Videos http://www.hot-squirt.com/squirting-beavers Squirting Beavers http://www.hot-squirt.com/peeing-shows Peeing Shows http://www.hot-squirt.com/woman-peeings Woman Peeings http://www.hot-squirt.com/woman-peeing Woman Peeing http://www.hot-squirt.com/seehersquirt-sierra-sin SeeHerSquirt Sierra Sin http://www.hot-squirt.com/ejaculation-movies Ejaculation Movies http://www.hot-squirt.com/pissing-in-public Pissing in Public http://www.hot-squirt.com/squirting-chicks Squirting Chicks http://www.hot-squirt.com/pee-pics Pee Pics http://www.hot-squirt.com/squirting-girls-videos Squirting Girls Videos http://www.hot-squirt.com/girls-who-squirt Girls Who Squirt http://www.hot-squirt.com/pissing-pictures Pissing Pictures http://www.hot-squirt.com/peeing-videos Peeing videos http://www.hot-squirt.com/teen-pissing-videos Teen Pissing Videos http://www.hot-squirt.com/teen-squirt Teen Squirt http://www.hot-squirt.com/pissing-video-clips Pissing Video Clips http://www.hot-squirt.com/pee-cam Pee Cam http://www.hot-squirt.com/squirt-videos Squirt Videos http://www.hot-squirt.com/peeing-pics Peeing Pics http://www.hot-squirt.com/see-her-squirt See Her Squirt http://www.hot-squirt.com/peeing-videos Peeing Videos http://www.hot-squirt.com/peeing-mpegs Peeing Mpegs http://www.hot-squirt.com/drinking-piss Drinking Piss http://www.hot-squirt.com/piss-drinker Piss Drinker http://www.hot-squirt.com/pee-fetish Pee Fetish http://www.hot-squirt.com/squirt-tv Squirt TV http://www.hot-squirt.com/pissing-gallery Pissing Gallery http://www.hot-squirt.com/free-piss-videos Free Piss Videos http://www.hot-squirt.com/peeing-pics Peeing Pics http://www.hot-squirt.com/piss Piss http://www.hot-squirt.com/squirting-links Squirting Links http://www.hot-squirt.com/peeing-shows Peeing Shows http://www.hot-squirt.com/pissing-photos Pissing Photos http://www.hot-squirt.com/seehersquirt-ariana SeeHerSquirt Ariana http://www.hot-squirt.com/hot-girls-squirting Hot Girls Squirting http

Categories

Search

Moonshine Patriots: A Note on E.L. Doctorow

By Charles O'Brien

Comments